Identifying a violent extremist in New Zealand with real intent and capability to carry out an attack is increasingly difficult amid an online environment saturated with potentially radicalising content.
Violent extremists in New Zealand continue to be influenced by a broad range of ideologies, online rhetoric, domestic and global events, and personalised grievances. A disproportionate number of young people are coming to our attention after adopting increasingly extreme political, social, or religious beliefs that are motivated by violence.
NZSIS is tasked with finding violent extremists – people who justify the use of violence in order to achieve radical political, social or religious change in New Zealand.
Part of our job is to work out whether someone’s vitriolic and violent online pronouncements have any link to New Zealand, and then whether they have the genuine intent and capability to take the next step and commit an act of violence underpinned by an ideological motivation.
This is a narrow focus but the pool of information and intelligence we are working with is vast.
We used to describe our work as finding a needle in a haystack. However, the internet has changed. Large volumes of toxic content, widespread anonymity, and hidden locations mean our job is now like looking for the sharpest needle in endless giant stacks of needles.
Extremist rhetoric, particularly online, has become more mainstream, a development which has made it even more challenging to differentiate between genuine support for violent extremism, hateful language designed to shock, or online content created simply to drive engagement or “likes”.
The most common violent extremist ideologies seen in New Zealand remain identity and faith-motivated violent extremism. However, cases where an individual’s beliefs do not fit within any distinct ideological category are now commonplace.
Read our definitions of violent extremist ideologies on page 33.
During these current times of global conflict, political and economic volatility and societal disruption, violent extremist narratives are becoming more normalised, particularly online.
New Zealanders have been exposed to groups using online channels to recruit or radicalise across all extremist ideologies.
Established faith-motivated violent extremist groups such as the Islamic State and al-Qa’ida continue to grow in some permissive regions across the Middle East, Asia and Africa. Due to the pervasive influence of the internet, these groups have been able to reach New Zealanders through spreading propaganda and other harmful ideological content.
White identity violent extremist groups tend not to be as cohesive, but their online recruitment tactics are similar, and they are finding willing consumers of their content in New Zealand.
It remains the case that New Zealanders are searching for, accessing and sharing this content, including the young and vulnerable. Exposure to such material can hasten a young person’s pathway to radicalisation, especially when there is little monitoring or regulation of their online behaviours.
Protecting Crowded Places